For those of you that have been reading with Carrie from Normal Level of Crazy and me through this online book club: WE LOVE YOU. Trying to make a go of anything new in this blogging world is can be tricky, but we’re going to keep up with this because, quite simply, we love reading. Also, most sincerely, we love you, readers.
After our last post, one woman told me how grateful she was to have someone else to read with, even if she never actually met them. She too is a book fan, but her young kids prevent her from the magic trick of leaving her house. Yet she still wanted to know someone else was reading the same book she was–and thinking about it and caring what she thought.
Being the sap that I am about connecting with others, I teared up when she shared this with me. And then I felt reaffirmed that this book club was a smart idea. I love my books. I can’t always go out like a normal person to talk about them face-to-face, but being able to read with all of you is a blessing.
So thanks for humoring us, friends–we are genuinely thrilled that you are here!
And make sure to leave a comment below to win a copy of our pick for this month!
***************************************
All that gushiness aside, our pick for last month was Yes, Please by Amy Poehler. This is hard review for me to write because I LOVE AMY POEHLER. But I was not a fan of this book.
As we noshed on chips and margaritas, I worked hard to put my thoughts into words so I could explain them to Carrie, but it’s tricky. My concept of Poehler is that she is sweet, genuine, very smart and wonderfully sarcastically funny. I simply could not get this image to savvy up with the voice in her book, which to me came across as cocky and even foolish at times. All quotes and input from other people featured in the book served to confirm my original notion of her, but her voice itself confused me. Did anyone else feel this way??
My admiration of her was also disillusioned by some of the book’s content. It was disjointed and confusing. For example, on one page Poehler both noted the damage drugs can wreck on a family, only to then seemingly praise drugs for their redeeming qualities. The flow felt bizarre and off to me.
Perhaps my feelings about the book mostly stem from my difficultly relating to Poehler. For while we have children the same age, our day-to-days are wildly different. Usually inability to relate to the people I read about does not color my opinions of books, but I think in this case, it did.
There were some very cool things about the book, though. Carrie noted her appreciation for Poehler’s recognition of the difficulty of book-writing, and I whole-heartedly agree. Poehler’s honesty about this was not only refreshing, but inspiring for those of us aspiring to write while feeling overwhelmed by the reality of actually producing a book.
I also delighted in the photos and excerpts that were included throughout the book. These served not only to break up text and provide levity but reinforced my original affection for Amy Poehler.
While I didn’t love this book, I remain a tremendous fan of Poehler’s work in general. I don’t think all authors are meant to write books, and this is fine. We need people to write amazing content for television so we can roll on the floor in laughter after we stash those kiddos in bed 😉
****************************************************
After hearing WONDERFUL things about Jodi Picoult’s Leaving Time, we decided to cozy in for the holiday month with one of our all-time favorite authors. Please join us and read along this month–we will look forward to chatting about it with you the first Friday of January!
And if you’d like to win a copy of Leaving Time, just tell us in your comment below. One winner, age 18 or above, living in the continental U.S. will be randomly selected from the comments left below before 12/12/14 at 5am EST.
Here is the summary for Leaving Time from Amazon, along with the link to buy the book:
Jodi Picoult’s Leaving Time weaves elephant behavior into a search for a missing mother. The connection isn’t as odd as it might sound at first, and Picoult has written another page-turning novel, even as it focuses on motherhood, loss, and grief. Teenager Jenna Metcalf was just three years old when her mother disappeared from an elephant sanctuary. Ten years later, she takes up the search for her mother, Alice, by studying Alice’s decade-old journals on grieving elephants. The research itself is fascinating, the hints about Alice’s disappearance are compelling; but Jenna cannot find her mother on her own. By enlisting the help of a formerly famous—now infamous—psychic, as well as a down-and-out private detective whose career went south during the botched investigation of Alice’s disappearance, Jenna forms a sort of new family to help her in her quest. As the facts begin to come together—described in alternating chapters by Jenna, the psychic, the private detective, and Alice’s journals—it all heads toward a thrilling conclusion. And, yes, there is a big twist at the end. – Chris Schluep
Looking forward to reading with YOU, friends! Happy cozy holiday reading!
First image credit: depositphotos.com, image ID:30508017, copyright:massonforstock
Latest posts by Meredith (see all)
- Slow Dance Book Club Discussion - September 13, 2024
- What Have You Done? Book Club Discussion - August 2, 2024
- Lies and Weddings Book Club Discussion - June 14, 2024
Meredith says
I love most of Jodi Picoult’s books, so I’m looking forward to trying this one!
Meredith says
Me too! I heard this one is REALLY good too, Meredith!
Courtney says
I was expecting to laugh with Yes Please, especially since it won Goodread’s comedy category. I found it well written, and I could Amy Poehler talking to me through her words, but it was not funny. I was hoping for something light, and it was heavier than expected. Overall, I’d encourage others to read it if they like her, but I probably won’t read it again, which is hard for me to say.
Meredith says
I know, Courtney. It was just weird for me, which really surprised me…
Courtney says
PS I REALLY WANT TO WIN THE PICOULT BOOK!
Meredith says
Me too! I can’t wait to read this!
TheNotsoSuperMom says
Holy cow! How is the time rolling by so quickly!?!? I LOVE LOVE LOVE this idea but I can’t seem to get with the program! And the book before this one was my IRL book club’s pick. I haven’t been able to make it to those meetings recently, but I thought at least I wouldn’t feel left out and could converse about it if I ran into anyone and I could STILL be pay off this discussion! Alas, this Fall/Winter season is kicking my butt! How to get it together soon! I love Jodi Picoult too. It seems we read one of her books at least once a year in our club. Looking forward to getting on board with this!
Meredith says
Do not beat yourself up! This whole life gig is crazy–especially this time of year! Hop in with us if you can–we’d love to have you, but we get it!
thedoseofreality says
Off to order it right now! I loved knowing as I was reading Yes Please that this post would be coming and I could see what others thought of it, too! So, I honestly did love it, but I can definitely, definitely see how some people would not. I personally feel like if you have read Bossypants, then you might be expecting something similar, which obviously this was not like that at all. I think what I liked most about Amy’s book is that I feel like she is a seriously good girlfriend who champions women, and I am all about that. I came away from it wanting to still be her friend, but I may not be cool enough for her. Tina, on the other hand, I still feel like we could be BFFs. Off to share this post!-Ashley
Meredith says
Yes! I was totally expecting this to be like Tina’s book (we are also BFFs, I’m sure), but it was NOT. Saw an ad for Amy and Tina’s Golden Globes appearance last night, and couldn’t help thinking I was crushing more on Tina now!
Sisterhood of the Sensible Moms says
I bought Tina Fey and Mindy Kaling’s books. I will be getting “Yes, please” from the library. Ellen
Meredith says
I loved Mindy Kaling’s so much, I can’t say. Giddily anticipating her second in 2015!
Sharon says
I’m so happy to have found a contest for this book! I’d love to win!
Meredith says
Can’t wait to read it, Sharon! Thanks for checking in here!
Yesse Martinez says
Would LOVE to win Leaving Time by Jodi Picoult <3
Meredith says
Heard it’s so good! Thanks for entering, Yesse!
Jamie S. says
Love Jodi Picoult! Any book of hers is worth the read. Happy Holidays!
Meredith says
Now I’m getting more and more excited to read this one, Jamie!
Denise says
I would LOVE to win Jodi’s book!
Meredith says
I know–would be so sweet, Denise! Hope to get my copy soon too 🙂
WhenCrazyMeetsExhaustion says
I second what Ellen said about borrowing Amy rather than buying her like I did with Tina and Mindy. Or I’ll just ask Santa to bring it for me for Christmas. 😉
Thanks for the honest review, Meredith!
Meredith says
Obviously a good call in my opinion, Steph, but hope you enjoy whatever you eke out time to read!
suzi failing says
love it
want to win
Meredith says
Thanks for following along here, Suzi! And I can’t wait to get my hands on a copy of this book 🙂
Donna says
I would love to win a copy of Leaving Time. Thank you so much for providing this opportunity!
Meredith says
I can’t wait to read this, Donna!
Donna Shaw says
I’ve read other books by Jodi and look forward to reading this book. I’ve seen stories on TV on elephant behavior and am very touched by their sensitivity. This book sounds as though the story would really appeal to me and my book club. I love the opportunity of possibly winning this book.
Meredith says
I really, really want to dig into this book now, Donna! It does sound like an amazing story.
Sisterhood of the Sensible Moms says
I heard mixed reviews of Pohler’s book so I appreciate your honesty and I have read EVER Jodi Piccoult book so I would have to read her new one too. Winning it would be awesome! Erin
Meredith says
Godspeed, then! Let’s get this book in your hands, Erin!
Teri says
Nineteen Minutes by Jodi Picoult was a book that shook me to my core. She’s an amazing author and I’d love to win the new book!
Meredith says
I’ve never read that one, Teri, but have been told that I must! At the top of my list now!
Lisa H says
LOVE Jodi Picoult!! I would love to win this book!
Meredith says
Sounds like it’s such a good one, Lisa!
Ellen Saladrigas says
I would love to win a free copy of this book. I love to read.
Meredith says
Yay! Another reading fan 🙂 Can’t wait to check this one out!
Jen says
Me me me. Me . Please.
Meredith says
I can’t wait to get my hands on it either, Jen!